It seems as though I spend a great deal of time either on the phone, returning emails, or otherwise not being productive, to talk to people about the “best concealed carry gun.” It’s as though people think that I possess some secret knowledge about what is truly the best carry gun on the planet. That is just silly. What works for one person will not work for another. I have, however, determined a way to steer my customers toward making the decision for themselves so that their selection works for them, not for the latest piece of firearms marketing they have seen. Here is how to do it:
When determining which pistol to buy for a defensive carry gun you must consider four things:
1. What is my goal for carrying this or any pistol?
2. Does this pistol fit me? Does it feel good in my hand?
3. Is it reliable and safe?
4. Can I shoot it accurately?
To take each point in turn….
1. People have laughed when I asked them what their goal was in carrying a concealed weapon. Obviously, a part of your personal goal is self-protection. There are other aspects of your goal to consider with respect to how a particular weapon will work for you. Have you considered your basic style of dress and how deeply you will need to conceal your weapon? If not, part of your goal needs to be “to be able to maintain weapon concealment without outer clothing, such as a coat, or to maintain weapon concealment while wearing a light coat, etc.” Or if you live in a very warm climate, you may want something like “to be able to carry a pistol concealed and comfortably while wearing my swim trunks…and the pistol should not be overly bothered by occasional salt water exposure.”
Another aspect of your goal to consider is knockdown power. If your goal is to be able to use a pistol to distract or wound (or possibly kill) an attacker, a .22 LR will do the job nicely. If your goal is to make sure an assailant is instantly stopped in their tracks, a larger caliber will be needed.
So first define your goal. Mine would read “to carry a light weight, moderately powerful, absolutely reliable handgun in all carry circumstances, with minimal need for open carry due to weather conditions or clothing restrictions.”
Are you trying to defend your life at your high-risk convenience store job? Or is the pistol for your nightstand safe? Try to imagine every permutation of how, where, when, and why you will carry this pistol. This goal statement will give you a good idea as to the probable size and caliber of your weapon, as well as any special durability needs you may require of it.
2. Does this pistol fit me? Does it feel good in my hand? I do not know, nor do I have any way to measure that. Try many different pistols. Take your time. Try different sizes of the same model. Do not forget about revolvers. Try EVERYTHING. When it fits you, you’ll know it. The sights will align easily. The balance will feel perfect. The grip will be the perfect size. It will feel like an extension of your body. When that type of fit happens, you will know exactly what I mean. If you have tried every handgun on the market and have yet to find one that fits, I cannot help you. Keep trying, or switch to pepper spray.
3. Is it reliable and safe?
In my opinion, most brand name pistols are adequately reliable for a self-defense pistol. If it’s a $139 super-value Jennings or Hi-Point, you should probably pass. Any major brand of pistol will meet basic reliability and safety standards. Just make sure you are familiar with the type of firearm you are buying and that you pay at least $300 for a new one. That limitation will weed out pretty much all the low quality cheapies.
4. Can you shoot it effectively?
It does not matter what Guns and Ammo writes about the newest, most reliable, most accurate pistol that has just hit the market. If you cannot shoot it accurately and effectively, it is nothing more than a moderately interesting paperweight. You must be able to hit your target. If you cannot shoot accurately and safely, please do not carry a pistol.
So given our 4 questions, let’s look at how they apply to some theoretical customers:
A. John came into the shop and asked for a .40 S&W pistol recommendation for a carry gun. He is fairly large, has been in the military, and has been shooting for most of his life. He works as a stock broker and is rarely caught without a shirt, tie, and coat. He wants it to be fairly small and light. What’s the recommendation?
This is the easiest one - anything. Due to his familiarity with firearms, he will be (or should be) capable of safely carrying pretty much anything. Since he wants it to be fairly small, that limits the choices. He wound up purchasing a Glock 23.
B. Susie came in with her husband Buford. Buford wanted his little honey to be protected so he wanted to buy her a 4″ .357 Magnum. Susie has refused to shoot a gun after being forced to fire Buford’s .300 Win Mag at the range. She’s small and petite, and really does not want to carry a gun, but will get one just to placate her husband. She left with a .22 double action revolver.
C. Bob came in with the latest copy of “Guns and Weapons for Law Enforcement” tucked under his arm. He wanted the latest H&K USP SOCOM that was written about in the magazine. He’s had some firearm experience, but equates the needs of a police SWAT team to his own personal protection needs. He has plenty of money and wants to be able to talk about what he has purchased at the range with his buddies to show that he’s “in the know.” Despite my best efforts, he left after ordering an H&K USP (not the SOCOM, though…had to have enough $ to afford the tactical light and laser sight).
D. Diane came without a clear idea of what she wanted, and asked for some suggestions. She needed a pistol she could carry on road trips and occasionally in her purse. She thought a 9mm would be a good weapon, based on what she has read. She has basic firearms proficiency. She wound up getting a Sig P230 .380 ACP.
Everyone is different when it comes to pistols. Many people have no idea what they need, or what they can handle. Some people buy a particular pistol simply because it is new and different. Whatever your reason for seeking a new pistol, ask yourself the four questions listed above. Listen to your answers and let them guide you in the selection process. Do not worry about which caliber has better “stopping power” or “terminal ballistics.” If you cannot get off a few well aimed shots, it won’t matter what the stopping power is. Do not worry about tactical lights, laser sights, or customization. All the tricked out gadgets are great, but they are not the core attributes you should consider. Will the pistol fit your goal? Can you conceal it properly? Is it going to be comfortable to carry under your Long John Silver’s uniform? CAN YOU SHOOT IT ACCURATELY?
So now that you have carefully considered your four questions and you have a clear goal statement, give me a call and we’ll talk specifics!
And I KNOW that despite what I have written, I will still be asked for some specific weapon recommendations, so I’ve listed mine here. These are the weapons that I either own or would like to own:
.45 ACP
1. Sig P220, old style, stock configuration, no night sights. 7 rnd capacity, shooting Federal Hydra-Shok.
9mm
1. Glock 19, stock, fixed sights, no night sights, shooting Federal Hydra-Shok
2. Glock 26, stock, fixed sights, no night sights, shooting Federal Hydra-Shok
.38/.357
1. S&W 642 Airweight, DAO, SS, .38 SPL, shooting Federal Hydra-Shok
2. Taurus 669 .357 Mag, ported, Nickel, Stock, shooting Federal Hydra-Shok
.380 ACP
1. Sig P230, stock, no night sights
2. Walther PPK/S
.22 LR
1. Walther P22
2. Beretta 21 Tomcat